Casey, Caylee and Xanax – a speculative timeline.

07 Aug
Tried to summarize in a timeline.

Here’s some pure speculation on what happened to Caylee while in the “care” of her mother.  

6/15 – Casey and parents not getting along- Father’s Day wkd- Casey feeling extra familial pressure, fights w/mom and decides to punish her by taking Caylee and staying elsewhere.

6/16- around 1pm Caylee is last seen leaving w/Casey both have backpacks and Casey says will be home very late if at all.

-Casey comes back over when parents are at work (sometime after 2:30pm) retrieves Xanax from stash or does anyone in home have prescription?
-Casey drugs the child as she’s done before but this time gives her too much and Caylee throws up/has seizures/gets violently ill?
-Casey panics and makes flurry of phone calls trying to call mom and dad at various numbers each 6 times along w/2 calls to unknown?
-Casey can’t get in touch with anyone, doesn’t get proper help and Caylee stops breathing.
-I think she wrapped Caylee up in blankets and trash bags and put her in the trunk.
-maybe put the ladder there- thinking I’ll put her in the water and say that’s what happened- later decides against that- can’t even accept that responsibility- or worried about drugs in system.

She rationalizes it -oops accident- they really should have answered my calls! This allows her to compartmentalize and not blame herself- she just needs to get rid of the problem. She begins to spin elaborate story to explain Caylee’s disappearance. Her parents are kept at bay by aggravation story- they are used to her using this child as a pawn!!

6/17- goes to Sawgrass apts as Zanny. I think Zanny may be a recurring character that Casey invented when she drugged the child -giving her Xanax and saying she’s with Zanny the nanny so she could go out and party. People often give their drug of choice a “name” so they can talk about it safely.

-she plans to somehow open a window (on the DL) so she can return later and hide the child in the empty apt – police would think hmmm…Zanny had access to the child and this apt- Casey could say- damn that nanny!
-She may have done this before –as an empty apartment would be a “child proof” place to leave sleeping child who’s been drugged.
-something didn’t work out- unable to leave an opening or she changed her mind?

6/18- goes home, backing into the driveway and borrows the neighbors shovel.

-plans to bury the child under the playhouse but digging is tough, she’s worried about parents coming home or she just changes her mind.
-flurry of phone calls could be to parents- trying to find their whereabouts and make sure they’re not coming home?
-not sure of the timing of these calls- if they’re later she could have been trying to solicit help- trying to figure out alternative place for the body.

Was plan B to dispose of Caylee where she wouldn’t be found??- perhaps in the water and then leave her car somewhere w/purse in it and torch it? Hoping people would assume they both died and Casey could disappear with the money she’d been stealing.
–If someone runs out of gas why would they take both gas cans? One is enough to get gas until you can get to a gas station.

7/3- Cindy despairs- writing of her frustration at not seeing Caylee- blaming daughter’s betrayal and jealousy (myspace entry in timeline update post)

Finally she crosses someone who doesn’t let her get away w/it – Amy tells her mom about stolen money and where to locate Casey =BUSTED.

7/15- Cindy has been kept away from Caylee for a month and she’s had enough- calls 911.

-Casey still tries to delay- telling her mom- she’s w/the sitter I’ll take you to her in the morning.
-Mom says nope- you’ve had a month–Casey takes a deep breath and tries to spin and stick to her story.

She has obviously been able to get away w/outrageous lies before -thus leading the cops around Universal before willing to let even that one go. That’s a super confident liar.

I think police have filed just enough charges to keep her off the streets and she may be cracking. Maybe she told her attorneys not to let family come for visit bc things they say could be “dangerous” – but its really bc its getting harder to lie to parents! bc you can almost hear it in Cindy’s reassurances –“I believe Caylee is still alive bc there’s no way Casey would put us through this” – I’m sorry but I think she would and is putting everyone through this charade.

I tried to make this one short because I went on forever below but I’m slightly obsessed and just trying to put it all together!


Posted by on August 7, 2008 in Uncategorized


Tags: , , , , , , ,

11 responses to “Casey, Caylee and Xanax – a speculative timeline.

  1. anon

    September 24, 2008 at 12:30 pm

    wow! i have to say that as SOON as i heard the phrase “zanny the nanny” i immediately thought… OMG that rotten bitch gave her kid xanax so she could go out!

    your piecing together of what may have happened is quite astute.

    i used to live in orlando and xanax is VERY popular among her age group… or at least it was >5 years ago. i’ve never heard of anyone giving it t o a kid, but you never know.

    i hope the police have explored this option.

  2. Sphinx

    November 23, 2008 at 4:24 pm

    Sounds like the police reviewed a camera from the Sawgrass Apts. and there was no Caylee, no Casey, and nobody else the day she claimed she dropped her off.

  3. Sue

    November 28, 2008 at 6:42 pm

    This is just what I was thinking when I did a search on the net. I think you are right on the money. They say that there is a grain of truth to the lies she tells. She said Zanny was the last person she saw her with. After Cindy Anthony started defending her with such viger, after all the lies, I think Cindy has mental issues too. Cindy and Casey both seem to have a problem being in the here and now.

  4. JoAnna

    April 10, 2009 at 7:34 pm

    I think your theory is very very close. There are a couple of things we have different thoughts about however. I believe that when she borrowed the shovel, she buried Caylee in a shallow grave in the backyard (hence the cadaver dogs) and actually was looking for another place to bury her.(hence, the pings). I think she found her place(maybe the airport) and waited for her moment to retrieve the body. However, not realizing what even a small amount of time will do to a body, she took the child from the shallow grave and put her in the trunk of the car to take her to the designated burial site,only to realize very quickly that she wouldn’t be going that far with the smell that was already filling the car. So she looks over at the site which she knew so well as a child and hurridly got rid of the bag in that spot. She never got the chance to return to that place to once again move the child. This being the reason for her saying over and over “I believe she is close to home” because everyone knows how she lies,and she feels that everyone will take that as anothe lie and not bother to look. Only; as you say,there is a bit of truth in her lies.

  5. speaktruth123

    June 2, 2011 at 8:42 pm

    I have followed this case from the beginning and have been recording the trial. Yourbtheory just seems to be correct!!! It’s crazy. Has anyone mentioned this? I was just watching joy behar show and she was interviewing that “cowboy” man who bailed her out and his theory is close to yours…

  6. Sivan

    June 7, 2011 at 9:07 am

    I get the chills thinking how accurate this sounds.. Especially now.

  7. Tricia Gremmo

    July 3, 2011 at 10:20 pm


  8. Suzanne

    July 6, 2011 at 5:43 pm

    In my gut, i know that this is true. I had breakfast with my mom today and I said “don’t you think zanny is xanax? I think she’s been medically putting that child to sleep so she could go have fun! Mom said, I never thought of that! I said “Seriously???” It seems completely obvious to me. I am glad I googled it and glad to know I am not the only one! I don’t think Casey murdered her child…I think she killed her accidently in a huge act of selfishness. Unless she has plastic surgery, she will never be allowed to live in peace once she gets done serving her time for totally misleading the cops and never telling the obvious truth.

    • Michele R

      July 9, 2011 at 9:52 pm

      I believe this is exactly what happened! (My sister’s name is Suzanne:) Zanny the Nanny was a drug she’d give Caylee to put her to sleep. Something happened and yes an accident happened, and poor Caylee died. I feel Casey died that day too and this sociopathic persona took over.

  9. AK19

    July 7, 2011 at 3:43 pm

    I just found this blog as well, and I agree 100% with your theory. I still can’t make head or tails of the fact that the defense actually claimed that Caylee drowned in a pool and they then covered it up. Who would do that? If it was an accident, it was an accident and this would all be over. Everything seems too fishy and I can’t believe this irresponsible asshole is going to walk. Ugh.

  10. Michele R

    July 9, 2011 at 9:49 pm

    I totally believe this! Zanny DID take her in Casey’s eyes and this is what killed her. So, does Casey think she is lying? NO, and in her own words “I keep telling everyone and they will not listen to me”
    Think about it…Now, re-read some of her statements and replace the Nanny with a drug and guess what…the whack is telling us all we need to know.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: